A follow-up to our June update on Southeast Asia crops
When we wrote about El Niño back in June, we told you we'd keep revisiting this topic as new information came in. New information has come in — and it moved in the direction we were hoping it wouldn't.
We also want to sharpen the focus. Our June post walked through the full crop list: pepper, cloves, nutmeg, ginger, turmeric, cardamom. All of those remain worth watching. But if you buy organic, one of them carries a structural risk the others don't share in quite the same way, and it's the one sitting at the top of that list.
What's changed since June
In June, the UN put the probability of an El Niño event at around 90 percent. That part hasn't changed much — if anything it's firmed up. NOAA's Climate Prediction Center moved its official alert status from El Niño Watch to El Niño Advisory on June 11, which means conditions are no longer forecast. They're observed. The chance of the event persisting through Northern Hemisphere winter now sits above 96 percent, with roughly a 97 percent chance it continues into early spring 2027.
The bigger shift is in expected strength. Back in June, forecasters gave the event about a 63 percent chance of reaching "very strong" status at its November–January peak. As of the mid-July outlook, the Climate Prediction Center puts the odds of a very strong event at 81 percent for October through December, with peak intensity expected in late fall or early winter. Model consolidation has the Niño-3.4 anomaly climbing toward +2.5°C, and all 30 members of NOAA's experimental SPEAR ensemble now project a very strong peak. There is credible discussion of this event ranking among the strongest since records began in 1950.
To translate that out of forecaster language: the odds didn't drop. They climbed by nearly twenty points in about a month.
Why organic is a different conversation
Here's the part that doesn't come through when you read general market coverage, because most of it focuses on conventional pepper.
Organic black pepper accounts for roughly 6 percent of global volume. That's the entire pool. And unlike conventional supply, it cannot expand in response to price.
You know why, because it's the work we do every day. Certification takes years, not seasons. There's a multi-year conversion period, documented input history, segregated handling and processing, audited chain of custody, and residue testing to clear. A conventional grower watching organic prices climb in October has no mechanism to sell into that market in November. The certification is the constraint, and it runs on an agricultural timeline.
That's the whole thing in one sentence: when conventional pepper tightens, buyers substitute. When organic pepper tightens, there's very little to substitute with.
In our June post we described how markets react before actual crop losses occur — importers rushing to secure inventory, traders becoming less willing to sell, stocks tightening ahead of any harvest data. That dynamic is real in conventional pepper. In organic, it's sharper, because the pool everyone is rushing toward is a fraction of the size and the buyer base competing for it has been growing considerably faster than supply. Retail premiums for certified organic lots have been running in the 40 to 60 percent range for a reason.
The market didn't start from a comfortable place
This is the piece that gets lost when El Niño becomes the headline. Pepper was already tight before the weather entered the conversation.
Carryover inventories in Vietnam — the world's largest pepper exporter — have been drawn down to roughly 40,000 tons. That is thin by any historical standard. Vietnam's current crop is running meaningfully below normal. India's production has dropped notably from prior seasons. Conditions in Brazil and Indonesia have been less favorable than growers hoped.
You can see it in buyer behavior. Growers and exporters have been holding stock back. Importers have shifted to hand-to-mouth coverage rather than building positions. That's a rational response to high replacement costs, but it also means there is no inventory buffer sitting in the system to absorb the next shock. Freight and insurance disruptions on Gulf and Red Sea routes have added another layer of friction on top.
None of that has anything to do with El Niño. That's the starting line.
What a dry season actually does to a pepper vine
We covered the general mechanics in June — soil moisture, flowering and fruit development, harvest timing, processing quality. Two points are worth drawing out specifically for pepper.
Pepper is perennial. Water stress doesn't just dent one harvest. It damages vine health and suppresses yields into subsequent seasons. The tail on this is longer than it is for an annual row crop, which means a strong El Niño in late 2026 is not purely a 2027 problem.
Organic growers have fewer levers. Conventional operations facing drought stress and the pest pressure that follows it have a wider set of interventions available. Organic growers are working within a narrower toolkit by definition. The same weather event lands harder on certified acreage — which is exactly the acreage that can't be replaced quickly.
Vietnam's agriculture ministry has already issued warnings about drought, water shortages and saltwater intrusion, with pressure on the summer-autumn crop and beyond.
Being straight with you about the uncertainty
Two caveats, because we'd rather you trust this post in six months than act on it this week.
Strength is not the same as impact. The Climate Prediction Center is explicit that even the strongest El Niño events don't produce typical impacts everywhere — stronger events tilt the odds, they don't guarantee outcomes. Regional effects depend on timing and local conditions. A record-strength signal in the Pacific does not translate mechanically into a specific tonnage shortfall in Đắk Lắk.
Forecasts move in both directions. This one went from 63 percent to 81 percent. It can go back down. The Climate Prediction Center issues an updated diagnostic discussion on the second Thursday of each month, and anyone making sourcing decisions should be reading those rather than reacting to whatever number circulated last quarter.
We're not telling you the sky is falling. We're telling you the odds have shifted, and organic buyers have less room to absorb it than conventional ones do.
What we'd suggest right now
Our June advice still holds — monitor developments, stay in close contact with suppliers, review your inventory position. A few things we'd add specifically for organic pepper:
Extend your coverage horizon. Hand-to-mouth buying is a reasonable strategy in a deep market. It's a poor one when the substitution pool is 6 percent the size of the main market.
Ask suppliers about certified acreage, not just current pricing. Whether a supplier can serve you in Q1 2027 depends on the certified pool they control, not on the number they'll quote you today. That's a different question than the one most buyers ask.
Qualify alternate origins before you need them. Multi-origin coverage is becoming standard practice for exactly this reason. In organic, qualifying a new certified supplier takes time you won't have in a shortage.
Watch the monthly ENSO updates alongside Vietnamese farmgate prices. The weather signal leads. The price signal confirms. Watching both together tells you more than either one alone.
If you'd like to talk through your pepper position specifically — organic black or white — reach out to our sales team. We'd rather have that conversation now than in November.
______________________________
We'll keep monitoring and updating as the season develops. As always, thank you for looking beyond the label with us.
Forecast and market figures current as of late July 2026. ENSO probabilities are updated monthly by NOAA's Climate Prediction Center.